Copycat Wendy’s Frosty with Jamie’s Whey Isolate

KristineKid Friendly, Recipes, Smoothies & Protein Shakes, Snacks2 Comments

copycat wendys frosty_main

You know I have a mission to make healthy things taste like the unhealthy counterpart. That is certainly the case with this copycat Wendy’s Frosty with Jamie’s whey isolate. I haven’t had a Frosty in ages, but when I first tasted this combo, that’s immediately what it brought me back to.

The key ingredient in this is Jamie Eason’s Lean Body For Her whey isolate.  You can purchase it directly here:  While you could use another protein, I can’t guarantee it will taste exactly the same.

I also recommend you use a good blender to make it, to get maximum thickness. I have a Blendtec and love it. Mine gets so thick I can turn it upside down and no spillage!

copycat wendys frosty 2_e

I’ve made it a few times, and even my hubby agrees that it tastes like a Frosty. My girls love it too (I split 1 serving between them). I feel fine giving it to the kids, as the whey protein doesn’t contain any artificial sweeteners.

copycat wendys frosty 3_e

So when you feel like something a little naughty, whip this up and it will fix that craving.

Copycat Wendy's Frosty with Jamie's Whey Isolate
Prep time
Total time
Recipe type: Snack
Yield: 2
  1. Put all ingredients in your blender. Blend until smooth. Add a touch more milk if you have trouble blending it.
Serving size: 1 frosty (makes 2) Calories: 180 Fat: 3.7 g Carbs: 18.5 g Sugar: 9.5 g Sodium: 203 mg Fiber: 4.3 g Protein: 20 g